Skip to main content

ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL WEEKLY

August 31, 1985
ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL WEEKLY
Not Official History, Not Independent
Evaluation
Bhabatosh Datta
Reserve Bank of India: Fifty Years, 1935-85 by E P W da Costa; Reserve Bank of India, Bombay, 1985; pp 161, Rs 50.
ON the occasion of the completion of its fifty years of operation, the Reserve Bank commissioned EPWda Costa to write a book "which would highlight the landmarks in the development of the Bank as an institution, bringing out in full flavour its major contributions as a central banking institution". Da Costa, very naturally, has not gone beyond his brief and the occasion was not one in which the Reserve Bank would be wanting to publish itself a critical analysis in depth of its working over the fifty-year period. This task, it may be expected, will be taken up by others. The official history edited by S L N Simha covers the first sixteen years in great detail, but an official history suffers from certain limitations. It is time that the later history was analysed in detail and an evaluation made of the success and failures of the Bank.
Within the constraints of the assignment, which spoke only of landmarks' and 'contributions', da Costa has written an eminently readable book. The chapter on the political and economic environment of the thirties gives a clear picture of the backdrop on which the Reserve Bank was introduced. The only vital missing point relates to the gestation period from 1927 to 1934 on which an interesting paragraph or two could have been written. It should also have been mentioned, without any suggestion derogatory to the Bank, that the Reserve Bank of India Act was finally passed in 1934, not because of the recognition of the monetary needs of the economy, but because the European business interests were insistent that power over finance and banking must not be transferred to Indian ministers before an independent central bank had been established.
The treatment of the subject in da Costa's book is historical and the account given is short but fairly full. Certain things have to be glossed over, like the position taken by the Bank when the Travancore National and Quilon Bank failed in 1938. More important is the rather superficial description of the role of the Reserve Bank in expanding the rupee circulation during the War, when it was made to accept large amounts of sterling and when half-hearted attempts to stem the inflationary pressures were found to be inadequate. On the credit side, there could be some mention of the positive part played by the Bank in saving some commercial banks from the serious pressures of the immediate post-War years.
Chintaman Deshmukh gets full attention, but the other governors are referred to only
casually. The full story of Osborne Smith's departure will perhaps never be told. Da Costa's statement that Benegal Rama Rau resigned in 1957 "apparently because of differences with the then Finance Minister T T Krishnamachari" is a polite understatement, when it is well known that Rama Rau was asked to resign within a very short time-limit. Perhaps the author did not want to go into the question of the relationship between the Finance Ministry and the Reserve Bank. There is thus no mention of the fact that important decisions were (and still are) taken without consulting the Bank. The most glaring example was that of the decision to nationalise 14 major commercial banks in 1969, which was taken without any discussion with the Bank. In fact, even the Finance Minister was not consulted. Of course, a golden jubilee celebration, with the Prime Minister presiding, is not the right occasion to raise the question of the autonomy of the Bank and its right to be heard when important financial decisions are taken.
The account given in the book of the recent years is rather superficial, though the chapter on rural credit is fuller than those on industrial development, export credit, etc. The chapter on 'Stabilisation, Destabilisa-tion and Restabilisation of Prices' does very little to justify the high-sounding title. And the rather purple paragraphs at the end of the book on "the most surprising of all political developments since Independence" and the "smooth, miraculously smooth, process of desirable change" could have been left out in a work which though commissioned as a publicity handout, is written by one who begins the book by asking Memory to hold the door. There is no reason why da Costa's memory should be myopic.
The book of course serves its purpose as a publicity handout. While many unpleasant facts are brushed under the carpet, the more obvious facts are there including details about the later careers of some governors. Some omissions could however have been rectified. For example, there is a table on the money stock (M1 and M3) from 1969-70 to 1984-85 in the Appendix, but the explanation in the text is sketchy. The historical information could also have been checked carefully. For example, it is not quite correct to say that under the Currency Act of 1927, "the government had the option of giving gold or sterling against rupees". In fact the option was given to the buyer to demand gold provided that he tendered rupees equivalent to the value of 400 ounces of gold at Re 1 = 8.47512 grains (i e, 1,065 tolas at
Rs 21. 3 as. 10 p per fine tola). Gold dealers could easily offer the required Rs 22,620 and that kept the market price of gold at a little below Rs 22 per tola.
A brief reference has been made to the Research and Statistics unit of the Bank. The book could have given a fuller account of the important work done by this unit and of the immensely valuable publications, besides the Bulletin. No serious student of economics can do without the Reports on Currency and Finance, the Annual Reports and the Monthly Bulletin and there is rich material in the various special reports and occasional papers. It will not perhaps be uncharitable to say that the general reader will get a better idea about the Bank from its staff publication on "Functions and Working" than from da Costa's book. But the book is apparently meant for a different clientele.
It is time that the Reserve Bank took up the preparation of the second volume of the official history, the first volume of which covered the first sixteen years from 1933 to 1951. An official history is not a substitute for an independent expert evaluation, but it provides the base for further work. A convenient cut-off date for the second volume will be 1969-70 covering the activities and performance of the Bank from the First Plan to the beginning of the Fourth Plan, i e, over three five-year plans and three years of 'plan holiday'. The seventies brought in a new position with the Reserve Bank at the head of a nationalised banking system and also brought the Bank face to face with the problems of severe inflation and of uncomfortable increases in foreign reserves. Probably the appropriate period of study for the third volume will be 1970-1985. If da Costa's evaluation-of the Bank being "poised for a new adventure" in 1985 is correct, that year ought to turn out as a water-shed.
Colour-Chem
COLOUR-CHEM's Chairman B M Ghia has reiterated his plea to the Central government of urgent revision of the anomalous import duty structure. At the company's annual general meeting in Bombay he said the extent of actual imports—totally unwarranted in areas where efficient import substitution has already been well achieved— should cause concern to all those interested in the nation's industrial base. Some sectors of the chemical industry in particular are being severely hit by the continuance of indiscriminate imports, though the national exchequer also pays dearly for them. Referring to the current working of the company, the Chairman says that in spite of turbulent conditions in some of the major consuming centres, turnover has been some eight per cent ahead of the same period last year. The company's project for setting up a plant for manufacture of meta phenoxy benzaldehyde (MPB) at Roha in Maharashtra is likely to commence regular production very soon.
1478
Economic and Political Weekly
Vol XX, No 35, August 31. 1985

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Behavioral Targeting

What is Behavioral Targeting?
It  refers to a range of technologies and techniques used by online website publishers and advertisers which allows them to increase the effectiveness of their campaigns by capturing data generated by website and landing page visitors. When it is done without the knowledge of users, it may be considered a breach of browser security and illegal by many countries' privacydata protection and consumer protection laws.

Why Learn Behavioral Targeting?

How Behavioral Targeting will help my business Grow?



When a consumer visits a web site, the pages they visit, the amount of time they view each page, the links they click on, the searches they make and the things that they interact with, allow sites to collect that data, and other factors, create a 'profile' that links to that visitor's web browser. As a result, site publishers can use this data to create defined audience segments based upon visitors that have similar profiles. When visitors return…

Explore SMM tools to make you grow further and succeed in the digital world

Social Media Marketing (SMM) has arrived. We need to make use of some key tools here. We bring information about these to you.




1# Later – Instagram Scheduler Later is known as premium social media marketing tools to plan your visual content marketing.It’s an easy-to-use tool to schedule and manage your Instagram posts via any devices such as the computer, iPhone, tablet or android so that you can manage your account from anywhere. It has an ability to add team members and this is a keynote in this particular social media marketing tool.
Pricing: Free Plan: Available It has afree plan that allows you to publish up to 30 posts and 2 reposts per month on an Instagram profile. There are also a couple of things such as it helps to socialize with Facebook, Twitter, and other marketing tools as well.
Other Premium Plans: For Individuals: 9$ For Businesses: 19$, 29$, 49$

2# Oktopost – Social Media Management aimed atB2B Marketing Ocktopost is a social media management tool which is specifically design…

eLearning

Is there any time in our Life where we are not Learning...???


if that's SO then how come we all are not Inspired and Excited about Learning?


How to combine the two Fun and Growth while Learning?






In previous times, before the trend of e-learning resources like studying management techniques, individuals who wanted to create educational material either to offer or for use within an company created paper-based material like guides, and rich the program with movie and sound material. Of course, publication posting, is still a big business. And the idea of generating an income by developing knowledge to be used in an educational or professional setting is still interesting for many individuals.
The conventional education and learning where a undergraduate gets to fulfill a lot of person & return his or her concepts is something that is losing with the e-Learning factor. There is just no physical contact & everything is just, exclusive when you discuss of e learning So, it is al…

Hacking-free

The Internet is the new lifeline to people and social networking sites have become intensely popular. This is the time when websites and blogs are the new identity address. It acts like an equalizer and eliminates geographical restrictions over emotions or opportunities. However, even this great system is not devoid of problems. The most intense threat in this case is hacking. What is hacking?  It is basically a technological process using which people, other than the owner of the blog, social networking page or website, might get access to these pages without the owner’s permission. With the various tools and computer language scripts that are being developed, Hacking is also gaining momentum. Here we can attempt to enumerate some anti hacking tips that might help people to prevent their blogs from hackers. ·    Update – New version of the blogging software is released to overcome the problems in the older version. Get in the top of the game by constantly updating your blog page to the…

Obama success via Link-spirals

How were Obama & Romney Competing in Digital space


2008 was the hallmark for use of Technology in Politics.Worlds Politicians shifted their attention to Social-media not because they were fancied by it but Politicians understood their presence and engagement with the new breed of citizens via Digital medium is Vital.

One of the finest mix of digital communication channels that even the techo-wizards are wondering TheDigital worldknows of Link wheel a normally used slang in digital-domain for linking their website with their own online properties by wheel-spoke arrangement.
The Secret is now out its not the Link Wheel but Link Spirals that Mr. Obama and his Genius Designed and Executed systematically. Politicians are now devising the Digital strategy as an Integral part of their Campaigns to ensure their win in polls.
Online Consultants have conducted enough Deep Research and have come out with the Best Practices Guide for Politicians going for Polls which enumerates detailed Do's a…